Why is everyone in debt?
Debt is sold as a tool for people who choose it. This piece looks at household debt: where it came from, why it grew when it did, and what keeps it in place.
WHAT WE ARE TOLD
Debt is a tool. Borrow what is needed, pay it back, build a record. The responsible are rewarded and the reckless are punished. The rate reflects the risk. The credit score measures financial health. The whole arrangement exists to give people access to money they have not earned yet but will.
This piece is about one kind of debt, the household kind. The card, the car, the student loan, the mortgage on the home you live in. Debt that pays for living. There is another kind, borrowed to buy things that earn more than the interest costs, and it works very differently. That one gets its own piece.
The household kind did not just happen, and it was not always here. It was built, recently, to do something the story leaves out.
Debt did not add to people's raises. It replaced the raises they never got.
WHERE IT CAME FROM
Debt as the normal condition of adult life is recent. Two things had to change first.
There are two kinds of consumer debt. One kind ends. The other does not.
The kind that ends is the installment loan (a loan paid off on a fixed schedule). You borrow a set amount for one thing, a car or a fridge or a house, and you pay it back in fixed monthly amounts until the balance hits zero and the loan is finished. There is a last payment, and it is built into the deal from the start.
The kind that does not end is revolving credit, which is what a credit card is. It showed up on bank cards in the late 1950s. Instead of paying off the whole balance each month, you can pay a small part of it, often just a percent or two, and carry the rest into the next month. Interest is charged on the part you carry. As long as you keep making the minimum payment, the balance can sit there for the rest of your life.
That is the difference. An installment loan is designed to be paid off. A credit card is designed so it never has to be. The minimum payment is what makes it work. It is set low enough that people can keep paying it, and low enough that the balance barely drops, so the interest keeps coming and the lender keeps earning with no end.
The law knows it too. Every credit card bill in America has to show how long it would take to pay off the balance if you only pay the minimum, and what that would cost in total. It is printed right next to the minimum payment.
The second thing that changed was the price. Until the late 1970s, most American states had usury laws (legal caps on how much interest a lender could charge). Then a 1978 Supreme Court decision let a national bank (a bank chartered by the federal government) charge its own home state’s interest rate to customers in every other state.
In 1980, Congress gave state-chartered banks the same right. So the card companies moved to whichever state would let them charge the most. South Dakota erased its interest cap in 1980, and Citibank moved its credit card business there. Delaware did the same soon after. Over the next few years, other states raised or dropped their own caps. Delaware's 1981 law even required each bank that came in under it to hire at least 100 people within a year. For credit cards the ceiling stopped mattering. The biggest issuers now sat in states with no cap, and the rate they set there followed the customer everywhere.
By the end of it, credit card debt had no built-in finish line, and no real ceiling on its price.
WHY PEOPLE STARTED NEEDING IT
By the 1970s the debt was cheap to offer and easy to get. Then people started to need it.
Here is what the pay number does not show. Your pay number goes up most years. That is real. But adjust it for rising prices, and the raise mostly disappears. What a typical worker’s pay can actually buy has risen only slowly since the late 1970s. And compared with how much workers produce, that pay has fallen far behind. Since 1979, the amount a worker produces in an hour has gone up about 140 percent, almost two and a half times what it was. The real hourly pay of a typical worker has gone up about 15 percent. Workers produced far more and kept a small slice of it.
Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.
Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).
Already a member? Log in
“Then a 1978 Supreme Court decision let a national bank (a bank chartered by the federal government) charge its own home state's interest rate to customers in every other state.”
- 01The difference between debt that ends and debt that doesn't
- 02How the credit score treats borrowing and paying off
- 03Why debt became the normal starting point of adult life
Every study in The Collective Archive links line-by-line to original statutes, patents, and corporate filings. Full source drawers unlock inside membership.



