Sign in
← Wealth
Wealth · The Salary Trap · 13 minute read

Why doesn’t a raise ever make you feel ahead?

Work hard, earn more, get the raise. This piece looks at what a salary is built to do, where the value of work goes, and why more pay has not meant more ownership.

From the piece

THE SURFACE NARRATIVE

Work hard, get the raise, get the promotion, save a little every month. Over a long enough career, the salary turns into security, and if it gets big enough, into wealth.

Or pick a high-paying field, negotiate hard and climb fast. The people at the top, the thinking goes, got there because they were paid the most.

Even the word sounds solid. Most people have heard where it comes from. Roman soldiers were paid in salt, the story goes, and "salary" comes from the Latin word for that payment, salarium.

The Roman writer the story leans on is Pliny the Elder, who wrote an encyclopedia of the natural world around the year 77. In his section on salt, he says salt had a part in posts in government and in military service, and that the word salarium was named after it. That is all he says. He never says a soldier was paid in salt.

The best-known fact about the salary rests on a sentence that never says it.

The story about where a salary leads has the same problem.

WHAT LINCOLN EXPECTED

On December 3, 1861, in the first year of the American Civil War, President Abraham Lincoln sent his yearly message to Congress. In it, he described how Americans made a living.

He said there were people who hired others, and people who worked for hire. Then he said most Americans were in neither group.

"A large majority belong to neither class," he wrote. They worked their own farms and their own shops. They did not work for anyone, and nobody worked for them.

So in Lincoln's America, most people worked for themselves. Working for someone else was where a young man with no money started out, not where he stayed. "The prudent, penniless beginner in the world labors for wages awhile, saves a surplus with which to buy tools or land for himself, then labors on his own account another while, and at length hires another new beginner to help him."

Wages first. Then your own tools. Then you hire the next young man.

TWENTY-TWO YEARS LATER

On August 28, 1883, a machinist named John Morrison sat in front of a committee of the US Senate in New York. He was about twenty-three. The committee was holding hearings in several cities, asking working people how their lives had changed, and every word was printed.

A machinist used to learn the whole job, shaping metal parts and fitting them together into a working machine. Morrison told them that job had been split into small separate tasks, and each task split again, "so that a man never learns the machinist's trade now." Each man learned one small task and did it every day. It also took far fewer men. "Through this system of work, 100 men are able to do now what it took 300 or 400 men to do fifteen years ago." Asked whether a man got so good at his one part that he could do it without thinking, he said, "In fact he becomes almost a part of the machinery."

Then a member of the committee asked him Lincoln's question. Could "a man who is temperate and economical and thrifty," meaning sober and careful with money, save enough in one of these shops to become a boss himself, without a relative dying and leaving him a fortune, "or without drawing a lottery prize"?

"Well, speaking generally, there is no chance. They have lost all desire to become bosses now."

He explained why. Their wages were too small, and starting a machine shop now took twenty or thirty thousand dollars. "It takes all they can earn to live."

The Senate printed his answers under its own heading. "Difficulty of rising out of the wage-working class."

Lincoln's ladder was twenty-two years old. A young man standing on its first step was already telling the Senate that, in his trade, the second step was gone.

For a man with nothing, the other old way out was to go west and farm land of his own. In 1891 the Census reported that the country no longer had a frontier. The unsettled land had been broken up so much "that there can hardly be said to be a frontier line."

THE CLOCK ON THE WALL

Once most people worked for someone else, the owner needed to know one thing about each of them. When did they show up?

In 1888, a man in Auburn, New York, named Willard Bundy patented a machine to answer it. Each worker had his own key, and the clock recorded the time he arrived. The patent says the workers would record their own arrival, to "save the extra expense of watchmen or time-keepers."

The company that sold Bundy's clocks merged with others and, in 1924, took a new name. International Business Machines. IBM.

THE MAN WITH THE STOPWATCH

The clock knew when a worker arrived. The next question was what he did after that, and who decided.

Frederick Taylor answered it. Taylor was an American engineer who stood in factories with a stopwatch, timed every movement a worker made, and wrote down the one right way to do each task. He called it scientific management, and in 1911 he put it all in a book, The Principles of Scientific Management.

In the book, Taylor is plain about where the thinking goes. Under the old way, the worker planned his own work. Under Taylor's system, "all of the planning which under the old system was done by the workman, must of necessity under the new system be done by the management."

Each worker got written instructions every day. They said "not only what is to be done but how it is to be done and the exact time allowed for doing it."

Taylor tested his system on men loading iron bars onto railway cars. He was just as plain about the kind of man that job needed. He used an old word, phlegmatic, which means slow and hard to stir up.

"One of the very first requirements for a man who is fit to handle pig iron as a regular occupation is that he shall be so stupid and so phlegmatic that he more nearly resembles in his mental make-up the ox than any other type."

That is the man who designed the modern job, describing the worker he wanted for it.

Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.

Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).


Already a member? Log in
The line worth repeating
“In 1861, Lincoln told Congress that most Americans worked for themselves. By 2009, only 1 in 9 did.”
Source: Abraham Lincoln, Annual Message to Congress, 1861; US Bureau of Labor Statistics, Monthly Labor Review, 2010
What you’ll understand
  1. 01What a salary pays for, and what it leaves out
  2. 02What Lincoln expected a wage to be, and what a machinist told the Senate in 1883
  3. 03Why a raise feels like progress, and what it changes
Built on
Interactive tool The Raise Reality Calculator See what your raise is worth after tax and inflation
13 minute readWealthDrawn from Lincoln’s 1861 message, an 1883 Senate hearing and Starbucks’ own filingAudio available inside
Questions this piece answers
  • Why doesn’t a raise ever make you feel ahead?
  • Why haven’t wages kept up with productivity?
  • What is scientific management?
  • Can you get rich from a salary?
  • Why do business owners make more money than employees?
Read alongside