Sign in
← Education
Education · The School, Debt, Labor Term · 10 minute read

Is student debt worth it?

Almost everyone believes a student loan can never be erased in bankruptcy. This piece follows how the loan was built, law by law, until it could reach a Social Security check, and the one way out almost nobody uses.

From the piece

THE SURFACE NARRATIVE

A student loan is an investment in a person's own future. Borrow now, earn more later, pay it back out of the better salary.

The other thing everyone has heard is that a student loan can never be erased, not even in bankruptcy. Almost everyone believes it.

Both beliefs leave out how the loan was built, and the second one, that bankruptcy can never erase it, is wrong in a way that matters.

THE MAN WHOSE SOCIAL SECURITY PAID HIS LOANS

Between 1984 and 1989, a man named James Lockhart took out nine federal student loans from four different schools. He did not pay them back.

In May 2002, the government began taking money out of his Social Security, the monthly federal checks paid to retirees and disabled workers. The first cut was $93 a month. His lawyer later told the Supreme Court he was disabled.

He fought it all the way to that Court. To see how a college loan reached a Social Security check, go back to a gym in Texas.

THE PROMISE IN SAN MARCOS

On November 8, 1965, President Lyndon Johnson signed the Higher Education Act. He did it in the gymnasium of Southwest Texas State College in San Marcos, the college he had graduated from himself.

The law created the guaranteed student loan, the program Lockhart's loans came from. A student could borrow for college, and the federal government would stand behind the loan.

For its first eleven years, that loan could be cleared in bankruptcy like most other debts.

THE WORDS "FUTURE INCOME"

Then Congress started to worry about one kind of borrower. A graduate finishes school, files for bankruptcy the next week, and walks away with a new degree and no debt.

So in 1976, Congress added a rule to an education bill. A guaranteed student loan could not be wiped out in bankruptcy during the first five years of repayment, unless a court found that paying it "from future income or other wealth will impose an undue hardship on the debtor or his dependents."

In plain terms, a judge could let the borrower out early only if paying would be too hard on him or his family, counting money he had not even earned yet.

Future income. The loan was being weighed against a working life that had not happened.

WHAT THE INVESTIGATORS FOUND

In 1977, while Congress was writing a new bankruptcy law, its own investigators at the General Accounting Office went looking for that runaway graduate in real bankruptcy filings.

Only about 8 percent of the filings they sampled listed a student loan as the person's only debt. On average, the people who filed owed more than twice as much to everyone else as they did on the student loan.

The investigators also found that these borrowers had paid back very little before they filed. So the runaway graduate was real. In the filings they read, that graduate was the exception.

Congress wrote the rule into the main bankruptcy law in 1978 anyway.

When Lockhart took out his first loan in 1984, it came with two time limits. Bankruptcy could clear it after five years of repayment. And if a borrower stopped paying, the government had six years to sue and ten years to take the money out of other federal payments.

Over the next fourteen years, Congress took both of them away.

THE DEADLINES COME OFF

The first change came in 1990, inside a crime bill, in a section about collecting debts owed to the federal government. It stretched the bankruptcy wait from five years to seven.

The next year, Congress took away the deadline for collecting. The law now says "no limitation shall terminate the period" for suing, collecting, or taking money from a student loan borrower. Most debts eventually run out of time. This one does not.

That same 1991 law let the government take money straight out of a borrower's paycheck once a loan is in default, meaning the borrower has stopped paying. The government sends the employer an order. No court is involved. The borrower can ask for a hearing, but an official runs it, not a judge.

One check was still out of reach. Federal law shields Social Security from creditors, and the 1991 law never mentioned it.

Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.

Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).


Already a member? Log in
The line worth repeating
“Between 2001 and 2015, about $1.1 billion was taken from Social Security checks for student loans. About 71 cents of every dollar went to fees and interest.”
Source: US Government Accountability Office, GAO-17-45, December 2016
What you’ll understand
  1. 01How Congress took away every time limit on a student loan
  2. 02Why the ways to be forgiven are counted in years of work
  3. 03The bankruptcy route that worked for 98 percent of borrowers whose cases were decided
Built on
10 minute readEducationDrawn from the 1998 conference report and the Supreme Court’s Lockhart rulingAudio available inside
Questions this piece answers
  • Is student debt worth it?
  • Can student loans be discharged in bankruptcy?
  • Why can’t student loans be discharged in bankruptcy?
  • Can the government take Social Security for student loans?
  • How long does it take to pay off student loans?
Read alongside