Why do companies profit when problems never get solved?
A dating app that finds someone a partner loses a paying customer. This short piece looks at what a business loses when its product works, and who replaces the people it fixed.
A dating app finds someone a partner, and that person deletes the app. A drug cures a disease, and the patient never needs it again.
Each time the product did exactly what it promised, and each time that customer stopped paying.
WHAT THEY TOLD YOU
The product is built to deliver the result it describes. The app wants the match. The drug wants the cure.
When the result does not arrive, the blame falls on the buyer. They should have stayed longer, or bought the upgrade.
And when people suspect something is off, the story they reach for is a hidden cure. Somewhere a company is sitting on the answer.
WHAT'S ACTUALLY HAPPENING
Nothing has to be hidden. When a product works, what changes is who is left to pay. A subscription is paid by the people who still have the problem, every month they have it. A cure is paid for once, and then that person is out of the market.
In 2021 the dating app Bumble filed to sell its shares on the stock market. To do that, it had to publish its risk factors, a list of what could hurt the business. One item on Bumble's list was "users finding meaningful relationships on our platforms and no longer needing to engage with our products."
Finding love was a risk factor.
In 2018 Sam Yagan, the co-founder of the dating site OkCupid, spoke on a Stanford business school alumni panel. Stanford's own write-up of the panel reports his point that the vast majority of the industry's revenue comes from subscription fees. Then he named his best sign that people were happy with a service. "I look at someone who was active and then lapsed, and then they reactivate."
The customer counts success by whether the problem is gone. The business counts it by whether the payments come back.
Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.
Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).
Already a member? Log in
“Bumble's 2021 stock market filing listed a risk to its business: users "finding meaningful relationships on our platforms and no longer needing to engage with our products."”
- 01Why a dating app listed finding love as a risk to its business
- 02What happened to a drug company’s sales after its cure worked
- 03The one question that tests anything sold as a solution
Every study in The Collective Archive links line-by-line to original statutes, patents, and corporate filings. Full source drawers unlock inside membership.



