Sign in
← Health
Health · The Depression Industry · 9 minute read

Is depression a chemical imbalance?

Depression is real, and antidepressants help many people. This piece follows the life of a prescription, from the reason it is written to years of refills, and looks at the record behind starting and the record behind stopping.

From the piece

WHAT PATIENTS ARE TOLD

Depression is real. It takes sleep, appetite, work, and the ability to get through an ordinary day.

Antidepressants help many people. For a lot of them, the difference is real and it lasts.

The explanation is simple. Depression is a chemical imbalance, usually low serotonin, a chemical that carries signals in the brain. The pill corrects it. If someone stops and feels worse, the illness was still there underneath, and the pill was holding it back.

Starting is well explained. Stopping is not.

The research behind staying on a pill does not reliably tell withdrawal apart from the illness coming back. So stopping can look like proof the drug is still needed.

Starting an antidepressant comes with a simple explanation. Stopping one can bring symptoms that look like the reason for starting.

Follow a prescription through its life, from the first appointment to the hundredth refill.

THE EXPLANATION THAT SELLS IT

A prescription starts with a short appointment and a simple reason. Depression is a chemical imbalance. This pill corrects it.

That reason works for both people in the room. The patient hears that something frightening is fixable, and that a broken chemical is nobody's fault. The doctor has one sentence that makes the prescription make sense.

It was never proven.

The idea started in the 1960s as a hypothesis, meaning an idea for scientists to test. The best-known early version, from 1965, was not even about serotonin. It was about a different brain chemical, norepinephrine.

Then it reached the public. In the mid-2000s, the website for Zoloft, an antidepressant made by Pfizer, told readers that depression "could be linked with an imbalance of a chemical in the brain called serotonin."

By 2006, four in five Americans asked about a person with depression named a chemical imbalance in the brain as a likely cause. In Australia in 2011, it was more than four in five.

Inside psychiatry, the view was different. In 2011, a prominent psychiatrist wrote in Psychiatric Times, a magazine for psychiatrists, that the chemical imbalance idea "was always a kind of urban legend." In 2022, a large review of the research found no consistent evidence that low serotonin causes depression.

Patients heard the idea from the company selling the pill. Psychiatrists read that it was a legend in their own magazine.

So the explanation many patients hear is more certain than the evidence behind it.

That does not mean the pill fails. A drug can help even when the story about why it helps is wrong.

But the story matters later, when someone tries to stop.

THE TRIALS THAT MAKE IT LOOK STRONG

The doctor writing the prescription did not invent anything. The doctor read the medical journals.

Before an antidepressant is approved, the company that makes it runs trials and sends every result to the Food and Drug Administration, or FDA, the US agency that approves drugs. Doctors mostly see a different set, the trials that get published.

In 2008, a psychiatrist named Erick Turner, who had once worked as a medical reviewer at the FDA, put the two side by side for 74 antidepressant trials.

In the FDA's files, about half of the trials were positive, meaning the drug clearly beat a dummy pill, a look-alike pill with no drug in it.

In the journals, 94 percent looked positive.

Same trials. Two different records.

Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.

Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).


Already a member? Log in
The line worth repeating
“The apparent efficacy of antidepressants in the medical literature was inflated by approximately 32%.”
Source: Turner et al., New England Journal of Medicine, January 2008
What you’ll understand
  1. 01Where the 'chemical imbalance' explanation came from
  2. 02How the published trials compared with the FDA's own files
  3. 03Why stopping can look like the illness coming back
Built on
9 minute readHealthDrawn from Schildkraut’s 1965 paper, FDA guidance and a 2008 NEJM studyAudio available inside
Questions this piece answers
  • Is depression a chemical imbalance?
  • What happens when you stop taking antidepressants?
  • How long do people stay on antidepressants?
  • Is exercise as effective as antidepressants?
  • Do antidepressants actually work?
Read alongside