Sign in
← Wealth
Wealth · The Ownership Exemption · 10 minute read

How do billionaires avoid taxes? Buy, borrow, die explained

Most people sense the wealthiest pay less tax than they should. This piece looks at the ordinary, legal rules that make it possible, without offshore accounts or secret tricks.

From the piece

Most people sense that the very rich pay less tax than they should. They are right. Ask how it works, and the answers come fast. Loopholes. Clever accountants. Offshore accounts. Secret tricks nobody else is allowed to use.

Some of that exists. But the largest fortunes do not need any of it. They use the rules exactly as written.

The tax system was never built around what a person is worth. It is built around what a person earns. The two are not the same, and at the top they come completely apart. The people with the most wealth hold on to what they own, and as long as they hold it, its growth is never taxed.

WHAT GETS TAXED

The system does not tax wealth. It taxes income. Those are different things.

Tax comes due when something happens. A paycheck is paid. A stock is sold for more than it cost. Wealth that just sits there and grows sets off nothing. And the very rich rarely sell.

A worker earns a wage. The wage is income. It is taxed before it ever reaches the account. There is no version of receiving a paycheck that avoids this. The tax is taken at the source, automatically, every time.

A person who owns assets is in a different position. Stock that rises in value is not income. It is a gain that exists only on paper. As long as it is not sold, it is not taxed. A portfolio can grow by tens of millions in a year and generate no tax at all, because nothing was earned. It only grew.

So the wage earner is taxed on the money they make. The asset holder is not taxed on the wealth they accumulate. One is taxed for working. The other is not taxed for owning.

THE PROBLEM THIS CREATES

An asset holder still needs cash to live. Houses, travel, the cost of a large life. The obvious way to get it is to sell some of the stock. But selling triggers the tax. The moment the gain is realized, the government takes its share.

So at the top, people avoid selling. Most of the very rich have enough income coming in already that they don't need to. For those who want more cash than that, there is another option.

THE LOAN

They borrow.

A bank will lend against a large portfolio. The stock stays untouched and becomes collateral. The owner receives cash and sells nothing. No sale means no realized gain. No realized gain means no tax. And the cash itself arrives as borrowed money, which the system does not count as income. A loan is something owed, not something earned. So it is never taxed, no matter how large it is or how it is spent.

A bank will not lend against the full value of a portfolio. It lends a portion, usually fifty to ninety-five percent, depending on what the portfolio holds. Against a hundred million, the owner can borrow fifty million or more. They do not borrow all of it. They borrow what they need to live.

Say the stock grows eight percent a year. A hundred million becomes about 108 million. The owner borrows four million to live on. The stock grew by twice what was taken.

The obvious objection is that the debt piles up. It does. Every year the owner borrows again, so the debt keeps growing, plus interest. But the stock grows faster. After one year, about 4 million owed against 108 million of stock. After two years, 8 million against 117. After three, 12 million against 126.

Three years of living on loans, and the family is richer than when it started.

Every year, large American companies send their shareholders a proxy statement, a report that lists, among other things, how much of the company its top people own. In 2021, one of the world's largest software companies reported that its founder had 317 million of his shares "pledged as collateral to secure certain personal indebtedness, including various lines of credit." At the share price given in the same report, that was about 25 billion dollars of stock.

In plain terms, he put up 25 billion dollars of his own company's stock as security for his loans, and kept the shares.

Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.

Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).


Already a member? Log in
The line worth repeating
“A share bought for one dollar that is worth a thousand at death passes to the heir as though it were always worth a thousand.”
Source: U.S. Code, 26 U.S.C. § 1014
What you’ll understand
  1. 01What the tax system actually taxes, and what it doesn't
  2. 02How the largest fortunes cover their living costs
  3. 03Where the approach works and where it breaks
Built on
10 minute readWealthDrawn from the Revenue Act of 1921 and the Supreme Court’s Tufts rulingAudio available inside
Questions this piece answers
  • How do billionaires avoid taxes? Buy, borrow, die explained
  • What is buy, borrow, die?
  • Are loans taxable income?
  • How much tax do billionaires pay in the US?
  • Do heirs pay taxes on inherited stocks?
Read alongside