Why does social media make you angry?
The feed feels angrier than it used to. This piece looks at how the feed decides what goes on top, who sets the price of a like or a comment, and what that scoring lifts.
THE SURFACE NARRATIVE
The feed feels angrier than it used to. Most people put that down to the world. People got angrier, politics got worse, and the apps just show it.
The other thing people say is that the apps give everyone what they ask for. Anger fills the feed because anger is what people click. Blame the users, not the code.
Both explanations leave out a document Facebook filed with the US Patent Office in December 2012.
A PRICE ON EVERY REACTION
Every time a person opens Facebook, there are thousands of posts it could show them, from friends, pages and groups. Something has to decide which one goes at the top. That decision is called ranking, the formula that makes it is called the algorithm, and the list it produces is the feed.
A patent is a company's legal claim on an invention, and to get one it has to describe the invention in writing. Facebook's patent, titled "Arranging stories on newsfeeds based on expected value scoring," describes a way to rank posts by what each one is worth to the company.
For each post, the system works out the chance that the person will like it, comment on it, share it or click on it. Then it multiplies each chance by a set number and adds the results up. That total is what the title calls the expected value, and the post with the highest one goes on top.
The patent says what those set numbers are. Each one "represents a value to the social networking system." Not a value to the reader. A value to Facebook.
It also says who picks them. The numbers "may be specified by social networking system operators," meaning people at the company set the price of every reaction.
And it gives an example of how they might be set. "Comments on a story may be more valuable to social networking system 120 than a viewing user accessing a story." A comment is worth more to the company than a person simply reading.
A person decides how to react. The company decides what each reaction is worth.
THE PROMISE
In February 2016, Facebook added a row of faces beside the like button. They were called reactions.
Sammi Krug, a product manager at Facebook, wrote that day how the feed would treat them. "We will initially use any Reaction similar to a Like to infer that you want to see more of that type of content." She added that over time the company hoped "to learn how the different Reactions should be weighted differently."
A patent on its own does not prove a feed ran exactly that way. Facebook's internal documents, made public in 2021, show that the company did put a number on every kind of interaction, and they show the prices. By January 2020, every emoji reaction counted as four likes. That month an internal note lowered each one to one and a half likes. In the same note, a comment of at least five different words, or one with a photo or video, counted as 20 likes.
In September 2020, another note read, "Anger reactions have been set to a weight of 0." The same note gave the reason in Facebook's own words. Content dominated by angry reactions was "significantly more likely to go against community standards," Facebook's rules for what can be posted.
That took the price off the angry face, but not off the comments an angry post pulls in.
THE BET ON ARGUMENTS
The 20-like comment goes back to January 2018. That month Adam Mosseri, then head of Facebook's News Feed, announced the biggest change in years. The feed would now favor "posts that spark conversations and meaningful interactions between people." He spelled out what that meant. "These are posts that inspire back-and-forth discussion in the comments."
So the posts the feed would favor were the ones people argued and talked under. Pages whose posts people did not "react to or comment on," he wrote, "could see the biggest decreases."
Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.
Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).
Already a member? Log in
“In the ranking code Twitter posted in 2023, a like added half a point to a post's score. A reply its author answered added 75.”
- 01What Facebook’s own patent says each reaction is worth, and to whom
- 02Why one reply on Twitter could count as much as 150 likes
- 03What changed when people were given a plain feed in time order
- Facebook's News Feed scoring patent 9,378,529US Patent and Trademark Office (Google Patents copy)
- Facebook internal ranking changelog, 2020Facebook internal document (the Facebook Papers), DocumentCloud
- Twitter's published ranking weights, 2023Twitter, on GitHub
- Frances Haugen's Senate testimony, 2021US Government Publishing Office
Every study in The Collective Archive links line-by-line to original statutes, patents, and corporate filings. Full source drawers unlock inside membership.



