Sign in
← Media
Media · Optimized Against You · 5 minute read

Can social media influence elections?

Social platforms are free because ads pay for them. This piece looks at what advertisers are really paying for, how the feed was built to deliver it, and why the same system that sells sneakers can also move a vote.

From the piece

WHAT USERS ARE TOLD

Social platforms cost nothing to join. Ads pay for everything. The user gets a feed of friends, news and entertainment. The advertiser gets customers.

If the feed is hard to put down, that is treated as a personal problem. Too much screen time. Not enough self-control. Something to fix with a timer.

Advertisers pay for space on a screen. What makes that space worth paying for is the chance to change what a person does next.

A platform earns money when someone buys the shoes, clicks the link, or watches one more video. So everything it builds is aimed at moving what people do.

And it works for whoever pays.

HOW THE FEED WAS BUILT

In 2017, Sean Parker, Facebook's first president, described the question the company started with. "How do we consume as much of your time and conscious attention as possible?"

The answer was to give people "a little dopamine hit every once in a while," dopamine being the brain chemical tied to reward, each time someone liked or commented on their post. He called it "exploiting a vulnerability in human psychology."

The rest was design. The feed has no bottom, so there is no natural place to stop. The next video starts on its own, so nobody has to decide to keep watching.

And every change can be tested on real users. Two versions go out to different groups. Whichever one does better on the number the company is watching, like time spent or clicks, stays.

The system does not need to understand a person. It only needs to measure what works on that person.

WHAT IT LEARNED MOVES PEOPLE

Testing at that scale finds what works, whether anyone likes the answer or not.

One answer is anger. It spreads even without a feed pushing it. In 2012, two researchers at the Wharton School, the business school of the University of Pennsylvania, studied about 7,000 New York Times articles. Making readers noticeably angrier raised an article's odds of making the paper's most-emailed list by about a third. Sadder articles were less likely to make it.

Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.

Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).


Already a member? Log in
The line worth repeating
“Facebook’s first president, on how it was designed: give people “a little dopamine hit every once in a while.””
Source: Sean Parker, Axios interview, 2017
What you’ll understand
  1. 01What makes space on a screen worth paying for
  2. 02What the feed learned moves people
  3. 03Why ads from politicians are a tiny slice of the money, and why that matters
Built on
5 minute readMediaDrawn from Meta’s annual SEC filing and Zuckerberg’s 2018 Senate testimonyAudio available inside
Questions this piece answers
  • Can social media influence elections?
  • What was the Facebook emotional experiment?
  • Did the Facebook “I Voted” button increase turnout?
  • How does Facebook make money?
  • Is social media addictive by design?
Read alongside