Are diamonds actually rare?
A diamond is sold as rare, as a tradition and as an investment. This piece looks at where those ideas came from, who created them, and what a diamond is worth once it's bought.
THE SURFACE NARRATIVE
A diamond is rare. A diamond is forever. It is the ultimate symbol of love, commitment, and devotion. The diamond engagement ring is a tradition passed down through generations, representing eternal worth for an eternal bond. The larger the stone, the deeper the love. The purchase is not a purchase at all. It is an investment in a future together.
Every advertisement and every jeweler's window tells the same story. A diamond is non-negotiable.
HOW RARITY WAS INVENTED
Most of that story is younger than it sounds. The stone is not as rare as its price says, and it does not hold its value.
For most of history, diamonds really were rare. A trickle of large stones reached Europe from India, and later a steady supply of small ones came from Brazil. They were jewels for royalty and the very rich. The earliest written record of a diamond engagement ring, according to the Gemological Institute of America, dates to 1477, when an adviser told Archduke Maximilian of Austria to give Mary of Burgundy a ring set with a diamond for their engagement.
Almost four hundred years later, in 1871, diggers in South Africa hit two enormous deposits on a farm owned by two brothers, Johannes and Diederik de Beer. From then on, Africa produced 98 percent of the world's diamonds by weight for almost ninety years. The rest of the world put together made two.
That was a problem for anyone selling diamonds. If every stone that came out of those pits reached the shops, the price would fall.
Cecil Rhodes, an Englishman who ran one of the competing diamond companies, solved it by joining forces with another operator, Barney Barnato. Together they formed De Beers Consolidated Mines Limited. Within about twelve years, it controlled the output of every diamond mine in South Africa that could be worked at a profit.
The method was simple. Own the mines. Buy up what the other mines dug. For decades, De Beers bought its competitors' output, so rival stones did not flood the shops. Long after that, a U.S. federal appeals court, sitting with all its judges, described De Beers' "undisputed position as the dominant participant" in the wholesale diamond market, where stones are sold in bulk before they reach jewelers, "throughout much of the twentieth century."
They did not mine scarcity. They created it.
THE PSYCHOLOGICAL CAMPAIGN
Controlling the supply was only half of it. A cartel, a group of sellers working together to control how much gets sold and at what price, can keep stones scarce. It cannot make anyone want one.
When the Great Depression hit, people stopped buying diamonds. In 1932, De Beers closed every one of its mines.
Seven years later, by De Beers' own account, it launched its first advertising campaign in the United States. By the 1940s, its ads were being made by N.W. Ayer and Son, an advertising agency founded in Philadelphia. The agency's own files on the account, now at the Smithsonian, include a piece called "The Diamond Engagement Ring."
The ads were only one part of it. The publicity files kept for De Beers, now held at Duke University, have a whole section on lectures about diamonds, a folder on women lecturers, and a folder of engagement ring promotion material.
Read this full study with a 7-Day Guest Pass.
Unlock the complete breakdown, its original filings, its short film, and two live searches inside Ask the Archive ($0 due today).
Already a member? Log in
- 01How a common stone came to be seen as rare
- 02Where the engagement ring tradition actually started
- 03What happens to a diamond's value after the purchase
- Sullivan v. DB Investments, Third Circuit, 2010US Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit
- N W Ayer advertising records, SmithsonianSmithsonian National Museum of American History, Archives Center
- De Beers publicity files, Diamond Information CenterRubenstein Rare Book and Manuscript Library, Duke University
- Anglo American annual results, 2024Anglo American plc
Every study in The Collective Archive links line-by-line to original statutes, patents, and corporate filings. Full source drawers unlock inside membership.



